Logo
International Journal of
Social Science and Humanities
ARCHIVES
VOL. 8, ISSUE 4 (2026)
Dignāga’s theory of inference and Aristotle’s syllogistic: A comparative study of the conditions of valid reasoning
Authors
Ly Luong Son
Abstract
This article examines Dignāga’s theory of inference (anumāna) in comparison with Aristotle’s syllogistic theory (syllogismos), focusing on a central question: what conditions render an inference valid and capable of justifying a conclusion? Drawing upon the Pramāṇasamuccaya and scholarly works by Hattori, Hayes, Katsura, and related literature, this paper analyzes the doctrine of the Three Characteristics of the Reason (trairūpya) - comprising pakṣadharmatā, sapakṣasattva, and vipakṣāsattva - as the defining conditions for the validity of an inferential sign (hetu/liṅga). On the Aristotelian side, primarily based on the Prior Analytics and Posterior Analytics, the study investigates the role of the middle term in the relationship between the major and minor terms, while distinguishing the formal validity of the syllogismos from the stricter epistemological requirements of scientific demonstration (apodeixis). The analysis reveals that while the hetu and the middle term can be compared regarding their mediating function, they cannot be regarded as fully equivalent concepts. Whereas Aristotle determines the validity of a syllogism through the structural relationships among terms and premises that make a conclusion follow of necessity, Dignāga evaluates the probative force of the hetu through its presence in the pakṣa and its distribution across the domains of sapakṣa and vipakṣa. In particular, dṛṣṭānta in Dignāga’s system is not merely an illustrative example, but actively serves to express anvaya and vyatireka, thereby illuminating the relationship between hetu and sādhya. The article concludes that these two systems should be understood as two independent models of valid reasoning, formulated within distinct logical and epistemological architectures, rather than reducing one system to the categories of the other.
Download
Pages:72-78
How to cite this article:
Ly Luong Son "Dignāga’s theory of inference and Aristotle’s syllogistic: A comparative study of the conditions of valid reasoning". International Journal of Social Science and Humanities, Vol 8, Issue 4, 2026, Pages 72-78

Please enter the email address corresponding to this article submission.

Dignāga’s theory of inference and Aristotle’s syllogistic: A comparative study of the conditions of valid reasoning | International Journal of Social Science and Humanities