Logo
International Journal of
Social Science and Humanities
ARCHIVES
VOL. 7, ISSUE 3 (2025)
Bridging the epistemic divide: A comparative ontological and epistemological analysis of advaita vedanta’s sattātraya and kant’s phenomenal–noumenal distinction
Authors
Dr. Dasarath Murmu
Abstract

This paper conducts a comparative philosophical investigation of Advaita Vedānta’s doctrine of Sattātraya and Immanuel Kant’s phenomenal–noumenal distinction. Both traditions address the tension between appearance and ultimate reality. However, their approaches reflect radically different philosophical motivations. Śaṅkara constructs a graded ontology to guide aspirants from illusion to liberation, rooted in the soteriological imperative to realize Brahman, the non-dual ground of all being [1]. Kant, by contrast, delineates the limits of human knowledge through a critical epistemology that confines cognition to phenomena structured by a priori categories, while positing noumena as necessary boundaries of thought [2].

While both systems differentiate what appears from what truly exists, their aims diverge: Advaita seeks metaphysical unity, whereas Kant defends epistemic humility and moral autonomy. The paper critiques comparative approaches that conflate Māyā with Kantian categories or equate Brahman with the noumenon. It argues that these traditions express irreconcilable philosophical logics—soteriological monism versus epistemic dualism. This analysis challenges superficial analogies and offers a model for responsible comparative philosophy that preserves both structural insight and conceptual integrity.
Download
Pages:31-34
How to cite this article:
Dr. Dasarath Murmu "Bridging the epistemic divide: A comparative ontological and epistemological analysis of advaita vedanta’s sattātraya and kant’s phenomenal–noumenal distinction". International Journal of Social Science and Humanities, Vol 7, Issue 3, 2025, Pages 31-34
Download Author Certificate

Please enter the email address corresponding to this article submission to download your certificate.